It can, but it is a smaller factor than condition and mileage. iSeeCars' car color study compared more than 1.2 million model-year 2022 used cars and found the average lost 31.0% of its value over three years. Yellow cars lost 24.0%, while white cars lost 32.1% and gold cars 34.4%.
iSeeCars compared inflation-adjusted MSRP with used-car list prices from August 2024 through May 2025. Those are asking prices, not dealer trade-in offers, so treat the numbers as a direction rather than a deduction.
The study's explanation is supply and demand. White and black are the most common colors, so buyers can shop around for the cheapest one. Rarer colors such as yellow and orange have more demand than supply on the used market.
The ranking changes by body style:
For Houston, the study lists yellow as the lowest-depreciation color at 22.1% and white as the highest at 31.9%.
You cannot repaint your way to a better offer, and you shouldn't try. What you can control is presentation and paperwork. Mileage still matters more; see whether high mileage lowers your trade-in value. For why a dealer's offer sits below its lot price, see trade-in value versus dealer retail value.
A dealer that needs your color may value it differently from one that already has three like it. PriceForMyTrade manually sends your request to local dealerships, which contact you directly. It is free to sellers, there is no obligation to accept, and offers are confirmed after a physical appraisal. See how competing offers work.