Probably "Good," not "Excellent." Kelley Blue Book's values FAQ says most people overestimate their car's condition, and that most of the cars it sees are in Good condition. Picking the right grade is the difference between a realistic number and a disappointing appraisal.
KBB asks you to choose Excellent, Very Good, Good or Fair, then shows a value based on your ZIP code, age, mileage, equipment and that condition. The same FAQ says the trade-in value assumes you chose the accurate condition. Pick a grade too high and the estimate you bring to the dealership is too high with it.
KBB's advice is to be as honest with yourself as possible. It posts the share of cars it values in each condition and offers a condition quiz if you are not sure. It also explains why trade-in values run below private-party values: the dealer has to recondition the car, perform safety inspections and cover other costs of doing business.
Walk around it the way an appraiser would. Note every dent, scratch, worn tire, warning light and stain. Check that features work, because KBB says that if a feature such as air conditioning is broken, you should deduct the repair cost from the value.
Then pick the grade that fits the worst honest description, not the best one. Our appraisal prep checklist covers what to gather before a dealer looks at the car. If you are comparing numbers from different sources, see trade-in value vs. dealer retail value.
An online grade is still your guess. The number that counts comes after a dealer sees the car, which is why more than one physical appraisal helps.
PriceForMyTrade manually sends your request to local dealerships, which contact you directly. It is free to sellers, there is no obligation to accept, and offers are confirmed after a physical appraisal. See how competing offers work.