It can. Carfax's History-Based Value tool lists how the vehicle was used — personal, rental, fleet or commercial — as one of the factors it uses to estimate what a used car is worth. Carfax does not publish a single dollar adjustment that applies to every rental or fleet vehicle, so treat use type as one history factor, not a fixed deduction, and remember that a dealer's offer is confirmed after a physical appraisal.
Carfax's value page says only Carfax History-Based Value takes certain history items into account when it estimates used-car values. Along with year, make, model, trim, features and condition, it lists number of owners, accident history, service history, registration history, open recalls and vehicle use, shown as rental, fleet or personal.
The same page's frequently asked questions repeat that other factors include how the vehicle was used, for personal, fleet, rental or commercial use. The result is a VIN-specific picture of what that car is worth right now, which can help whether you are buying, trading in, selling or getting an appraisal.
That is a different question from how the number of owners can affect a trade-in or how a reported accident can affect value. Use type is another line in the same history report, not a substitute for those items.
Some history items, such as a reported accident, come with published average examples on Carfax's site. Vehicle use does not. Carfax tells you that use type is part of the calculation and that you can look up a VIN-specific value, but it does not give a standard dollar figure for a former rental or fleet car.
That matters if you are shopping offers. A lower estimate can reflect mileage, condition, equipment, demand in your area and other history, not only the fact that the car was once in a rental or commercial fleet. Do not assume a rental past automatically wipes out the car's value, and do not assume it will be ignored.
Look up the Carfax History-Based Value on the VIN, and read the vehicle history report so you can see what was actually reported. When you request offers, share the VIN and be ready to explain the use history, service records and current condition.
PriceForMyTrade manually sends your request to local dealerships, which contact you directly. It is free to sellers, there is no obligation to accept, and offers are confirmed after a physical appraisal. See how competing offers work.