It can. Carfax's vehicle history report page lists the number of previous owners as part of the ownership history that goes into a car's History-Based Value. In its example, a 2009 GMC Yukon Denali is valued at $27,630 as a one-owner car and $25,020 with three owners.
How the car was used is another history item in the same valuation family; see whether a rental history lowers trade-in value.
Those figures are Carfax's illustration for one model, not a fixed deduction that applies to every trade-in. Mileage, condition, options and the local market still matter, and a dealer's offer is confirmed only after a physical appraisal.
Carfax also lists other history items that feed the same value, including accident history, service history and how the vehicle was used (personal, rental, fleet or commercial). Mileage and reported accidents have their own effects; see whether high mileage lowers your trade-in value and whether an accident lowers your trade-in value.
Our practical recommendations:
PriceForMyTrade manually sends your request to local dealerships, which contact you directly. It is free to sellers, there is no obligation to accept, and offers are confirmed after a physical appraisal. See how competing offers work.